Ten years in the writing – WWII novel All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr

Anthony Doerr’s All the Light We Cannot See skillfully combines historical fiction, human strength, and moral choices of World War II. Set in Nazi-occupied France, the novel follows Marie-Laure LeBlanc and Werner Pfennig, two young heroes whose stories explore innocence, survival, and human kindness.

Doerr’s prose is lush, vivid, and carefully crafted, creating vivid mental images. The non-linear storytelling, jumping between different times and perspectives, enhances the story’s richness and complexity, leading up to the siege of Saint-Malo. Some may think the book is slow-paced, especially in longer parts. Being a Hemmingway fan, I understand the benefit of conciseness. But I did not find the pros tedious at all. It flows well without being overly flowery.

Marie-Laure, a blind French girl, is an intriguing character. Her journey from Paris to Saint-Malo, guided by her father’s models, showcases her resilience and unique perspective on the world. Her heightened senses, particularly touch and sound, reveal her inner strength. Werner Pfennig’s perspective on Marie-Laure’s story contrasts with his own experiences as a German boy caught in the Nazi war machine. His choices and rebellion against the regime highlight personal values clashing with societal expectations. Some critics find his character development rushed, especially in the book’s later parts where his redemption is abrupt.

The book effectively portrays side characters like Etienne, Marie-Laure’s great-uncle, and Madame Manec, the housekeeper who aids the resistance. Their courageous acts demonstrate kindness even in darkness.

Some find the pacing uneven, with detailed descriptions slowing the story. The resolution of major arcs is criticized for abruptness or lack of emotional impact. The ending, while moving, may be clichéd or unsatisfying for those invested in the characters’ journeys. None of this is any problem for me, and it may be nitpicking. The book raises ethical questions about tough decisions and the coexistence of cruelty and kindness. However, some critics argue that it simplifies characterization, often portraying characters as either good or evil. I enjoyed the themes, and I don’t agree that characters are blatantly good or evil. There is nuance..

All the Light We Cannot See, a Pulitzer Prize-winning book, is a beautiful and ambitious work. Though some parts are slow or boring, it’s moving and evokes both sadness and happiness. It showcases the human spirit’s strength in war. Doerr’s writing skillfully creates a complex story with beautiful language. However, some may disagree about the balance between light and darkness in his portrayal.